Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

Unstuck, a word in the original perimeter appears again elsewhere in the substituted perimeter

Unstuck, I think you have to proceed as Mack suggested. If you have the hint from corrected misprints, that may help with one section. I found the right hand column the most useful because there are several letters which have very few alternatives and this enables you to place those letters elsewhere, as well as allowing you to guess the entry for that column.

Well, that was absolutely marvellous from start to finish. Excellent work Mr Snaky.

My only slight quibble is the relevance of the left hand perimeter entry, which seems to have a very tenuous connection to the whole thing unless I'm missing something?

Smellyharry and others - Agree with your assessment of the puzzle. Loved working my way slowly but surely through this. Not too worried about the left-hand column as I can sort of justify it mentally but totally bewildered by the Fisher reference. It hardly seems likely that Statistics correlation comes into this and using the codes, either way, I can't make any sense of what results. Would love to know the relevance. or at least to get a hint of where to look.

Is Fisher a play on the thematic name?

Fisher seems a clear play on 1a and may also refer to a parable involving 19d. The final 13d seemed complementary, although I hoped for a second it was part of a whisper campaign to return Surrey's Matthew Fisher to the England XI.

I found a cypher insofar as there seemed only one possible substitution for each letter in the perimeter answers, but others may have seen more to it.

I agree that Fisher is connected to 1a.

Surely, the left and right columns point to how we know that the shape is a 1a 7a?

Rhsl, I agree. I was puzzled by an earlier post which suggested that the shape contained no right angle. I have a solution which is one of only five, apparently, that satisfies the whole perimeter and corresponds nicely to the proportions of the grid.

That's why I don't like 13d. I dont think there is a right angle in the desired shape, so it's somewhat misleading.

The bottom row suggests a size that can't satisfy the top row and have a right angle. The shape I have is completely unconnected to 13d.

Still a great puzzle though.

I still think I have a solution which satisfies all four sides of the perimeter and has a right angle so I don't understand why others think that is not possible.