Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

ror otbers = for others!
Fat fingers strike again

Hi plutocrat
The best that I can offer for 6d is that if I were [solution] I might shout ‘I’m here!’
Not very convincing, I know. I wonder if AI might do better 😉

…or someone in the house might say … the Police are here, quick run!

Hi Roger,

I don't want to speak for Plutocrat, but my problem with 6d is that it's verging on gibberish. I know it has to say 'other toad' for obvious reasons, but really:

Q. "who's here"?

A. "It's the other toad in soup"

I can't recall, offhand anyway, a clue that has made less sense.

Hi Brendan
I agree that it’s a terrible surface (contributing greatly to my general feeling of ‘oh well then’ about the crossword as a whole), but I understood plutocrat to be querying the parsing (specifically the last word) rather than the sense or otherwise of the clue as a whole.

Might 6d be some kind of allusion to "Toad of Toad Hall" or "The Wind in the Willows"? The clunkiness would then be due to working that in.

It's interesting you should say that Geeker. Before offering my opinion on the matter, I specifically asked Google AI if there was any story, proverb, joke, novel etc. that mentioned a toad turning up.......

The answer was 'no'

I know Google AI isn't the best, but still.

My Google investigation also led to a "no", Brendan. But I was hoping an allusion would excuse the forced structure of the clue.

Als (chrise and others), 21 was my COD because the expected 3-letter "parrot", though appearing in the solution, didn't parse because another "parrot" was actually used.

"Also" ...

Perhaps 6D is simpler than it seems, i.e. "fodder (other toad), anagrind (in soup), definition (here), with the surface an allusion to "boiling a frog"