Thepost, I agree with several of your points. I'm trying to temper my own criticisms recently, simply because I've been vocal for a long time. But, yes, the different grid constructions didn't really constitute a crossword. And while I welcomed any reference to philosophy, I too wasn't really happy with the merger of elements.
But I disagree on one thing you say : though you are correct that I defected (more accurately my AB sign-on was cancelled), there were always good advisers on this forum. Kilgore Trout no longer contributes, though I hope he is well. DJA is consistently helpful, and probably a quicker solver than me...and there are many others on the forum who contribute in similar spirit...it works well.