Many thanks jazzy, if only I could have seen your expression I might assume a compliment :-), but I do hope I don't come across as pompous and I am genuinely trying to help as I appreciate from earlier threads elle is keen to progress her understanding of cryptics.
Hi chrise, I agree that would have made the clue more of an &lit but perhaps the setter was deliberately trying to mislead and I was merely trying to show this as a possibility but we all agree it does work as it stands.