CancelReport This Post

Please fill out the form below with your name, e-mail address and the reason(s) you wish to report this post.

 

Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

rusty

25th April 2018, 22:13
Hello, Elle!
I think the sloths hang upside down from a tree branch.
I think they are very slow moving, rather than lazy!
I do not think I have read an Agatha Christie book, that I can remember.
I am sure there will be many copies on Amazon.
If the serial is only based on Agatha Christie's book there may well be differences.
I think that is fairly normal when books are being transformed into a film.
Hence "screenwriters".
20699 of 30765  -   Report This Post

elle

25th April 2018, 22:39
Update, Rusty!
Whilst searching for the book, I came across an article describing how and where ( no why?) the miniseries differs from Agatha Christie's original story.
I am gobsmacked....why bother to alter something so very much?
Why not write a completely "fresh" theme, if the original plot is going to be so distorted?
Not even the "murderer" turned out to be the same person!!!
I think very probably from what I have just discovered, , that I did indeed read the original tale many years ago....I just did not recognise it from the TV adaptation!
This mutilation of a written story on conversion to a film is one of my pet hates!
Grrrh!
20700 of 30765  -   Report This Post

rusty

25th April 2018, 22:44
Hello, Elle,
I think the vast majority of books are changed for the film.
Not really sure why.
But it happens!
And are you going to buy the book now?
20701 of 30765  -   Report This Post

elle

25th April 2018, 23:01
Hi, Rusty!
I really detest this practice of changing details, especially ruining endings, of a book to create a film with supposedly more "box-office" appeal.
No, now that I have read all about how the plot was changed... a good "classic" story ruined in my view.....I shall not bother to re-read the book.
I have been reminded of the theme and the correct ending now.
I wonder why ever the screenwriter should think that he /she can do a better job than Agatha Christie?
I think the alterations in such instances rarely (if ever?) enhance the original story?
I need a strong coffee.......
20702 of 30765  -   Report This Post

rusty

26th April 2018, 06:03
Good morning, Elle!
Looks a fine day outside.
Lots of folk who watch a film will not have read the book so will be quite happy with the plot etc.
I think when they made "South Pacific", the author of "Tales of the South Pacific", James Michener, was brought in to help with the screenplay, in effect changing his own book to suit the film.
It was a very successful film.
I hope this fine weather holds!
20703 of 30765  -   Report This Post

elle

26th April 2018, 09:36
Good morning, Rusty!
It is a sunny day here, but cold!
I have been out for my walk, and am now home again , this time with TWO dogs!
We are looking after friends' dog for the day, as they are attending a funeral out in Essex.
The dog is very elderly and arthritic and will need to be helped up the terrace steps to the garden, but she is well used to us so she will be quite happy .
I have a friend arriving later for lunch.
As you know, Thursday is normally "Ladies who Lunch" day ..........but today I am cooking lunch at home, because of the "dog-sitting"!
Right , time for a quick coffee.....
Are you doing anything in particular today?
20704 of 30765  -   Report This Post

rusty

26th April 2018, 10:12
Hello, Elle!
Lovely morning here, now.
I hope your lunch goes well!
And the doggie sitting!
I have no plans today.
Finished the puzzle.
More new words and meanings for me!
These setters are determined to educate us...well, me anyway!
20705 of 30765  -   Report This Post

rusty

26th April 2018, 10:19
Update, Elle!
I am getting ads on the right hand side of the page.
I do not mind that, really.
But one of them is for "Harry's Razors", and in the ad the word "expensiver" is used.
I have not came across "expensiver" before and it is not in my Chambers.
Have you came across it?
Maybe American?
20706 of 30765  -   Report This Post

elle

26th April 2018, 10:48
Hi, Rusty!
I haven't got beyond the top left hand corner of the puzzle as yet....
"Saddhu" is a new word for me but easy enough to get!
I shall have to put the crossword on hold till later, as my friend will be arriving in about five minutes.
No, I agree with you....I don't think there is such a word as "expensiver"......
The comparative should be "more expensive"....and the superlative is "most expensive".
Peace is reigning here....my husband and the two dogs have fallen asleep.....
The cat, though, is on vigilante duty.......just in case the 'alien' dog moves!
I shan't get the chance to use the computer again till around teatime, when my friend leaves.............
Catch up with you then!
20707 of 30765  -   Report This Post

elle

26th April 2018, 16:45
Good afternoon, Rusty!
What a strange day we have had weatherwise.......lots of beautiful sunshine intermingled with very heavy rain showers.
My friend has just left for home......hopefully she will just manage to avoid the worst of the rush hour traffic.
Lunch ( although I say it myself) was very good!
And it made a nice change to stay in, and chat, rather than head out for a restaurant.
We still have our canine visitor - she is being very good!
She seems very relaxed...and sleeps a lot , but we have been out in the garden and she 's enjoyed a wander round.
I don't think her owners will get back before about 6 or 7pm.
I shall give both dogs their "dinner" very shortly.
How has your day been?
Is your son coming as usual to see you this evening?
20708 of 30765  -   Report This Post