We have a tie between BBM2@3 and Paul@7, with Syzygy@9 as the runner up. A fairly impossible choice, but I'll go with Paul's
Old city bar member meets demise in modern myth (5,6)
Congratulations, here is your prize:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvjTpVCQg94
(I decided to spare you from the urban legends compilations,)