Will try it some time - maybe not this weekend because there's an Azed competition puzzle coming up that might be a time-consumer - thanks for the recommendation. I think that's the only barred one I haven't done now, having finished a Listener puzzle a few weeks ago (the relatively easy Bohemian Rhapsody one, admittedly!).
I think the i is missing a trick by continuing to print old Independent crosswords, especially as The Inquisitor move seems to have been a success. Why not print the ones that are currently online on The Independent's site? It wouldn't cost that much more in setters' fees, and I think it would definitely boost sales. (The fact that the Saturday i puzzle has a DAB radio as a prize, yet the answers can easily be found by googling a clue that will lead you to an old blog at fifteensquared.net with all the answers is ridiculous.) I don't 'alf go on, don't I? :-D